Hahah I had no idea about all these outcomes. I literally rolled up and lassoed him while he was teaching his son on with the horse lol. I cut that dialogue real short I guess
I just hogtied him & then his wife. And throw her in the water tried to killed the son but game doesn't allow don't know why. When i came back to take him to police for bounty. He told me karma will get back to you & the next mission arthur got to know about his death (tuberculosis) 😢.
After that i not did a single unnecessary bad thing & only help everyone
I remember i was fast travelling from and back to rhodes so i can get the scene of his execution just to save him- only to realize i couldn't reach for my gun so i couldn't save him in the very last moment as i wanted. After quick restart i never got this event ever again, so it seems by accident i served myself something i gave o'driscolls few chapters later.
Tied up him after he said his last farewells to the family… Just to tie up his wife, drag and drop her so that their faces would stare at each other and shoot her in the head with double-barelled shotgun. I think my Mark Johnson still has pieces of her brains somewhere in his nostrils or hair. The only thing I did wrong was to let the boy go, idk why you can't shoot him in the leg when he's running, but I guess that's just for the later scene.
I didn’t let him say his farewell and killed his wife. He complains to the sheriff that I killed his wife. Arthur just plays it off as part of the job lmao. Low honor player
I found very sad when u break into the house of two black ppl and u have to take down the father and then u hear all the time the son crying under his bed
you can pretty much save him by hanging just dont follow him cause he will get shot by lawmans if he rode to saint denis if you continue following him he ain't disappearing
In my run first i accepted his request then arrest him after killing his pals on the way then when it's hanging time i shot him free from his noose but whether he escape or not i don't know. Guy has a family so i gave him a chance. Don't at me!
I tried this mission so many times to try to spare the dude, it wouldn't let me. that's the most annoying part about rockstar games, free and open world, until you enter a mission, then it's super restrictive
Opossum Shulgin
08.08.2023I rode up guns blazing. Shot his wife in the face and would have killed the son of it would have let me lol.
Ali Haris
08.08.2023I feel like a horrible man after shooting his wife in the head
TheRealBritLad
08.08.2023I shot his wife when i did this mission
Chiefs_fan15
08.08.2023Hahah I had no idea about all these outcomes. I literally rolled up and lassoed him while he was teaching his son on with the horse lol. I cut that dialogue real short I guess
乃ㄥㄩ几ㄒ千卂ㄒ
08.08.2023I killed him and his wife I feel bad now
Gi
08.08.2023Freed him when he was bout to get hanged
PenguinMan
08.08.2023His wife looks crazy ngl
Ronin007
08.08.2023I just hogtied him & then his wife. And throw her in the water tried to killed the son but game doesn't allow don't know why. When i came back to take him to police for bounty. He told me karma will get back to you & the next mission arthur got to know about his death (tuberculosis) 😢.
After that i not did a single unnecessary bad thing & only help everyone
Chien Sun
08.08.2023Lol I just murdered his wife in front of him and his son, as a punishment for he tried to kill me with three strangers
Sztaborn
08.08.2023I remember i was fast travelling from and back to rhodes so i can get the scene of his execution just to save him- only to realize i couldn't reach for my gun so i couldn't save him in the very last moment as i wanted.
After quick restart i never got this event ever again, so it seems by accident i served myself something i gave o'driscolls few chapters later.
purple creature 3600
07.08.2023I killed the woman tied up mark and shot at his son nobody's gettin in the way of my 25 bucks
lacapaca123 • 3.5B views • 5 months ago
07.08.2023I killed his family, hanged them, made him watch and got his bounty
Marshall
07.08.2023Hello, where did you got your hat?
phillip walling
07.08.2023Why would you aim at Alden? He's our man!
Adyn
07.08.2023I feel bad for that man
D R
07.08.2023i took another option, I waited until he was on the gallows and shot the sheriff and his rope and he ran free.
Bruzh
07.08.2023When his gang attacked me… I came back to his wife and killed her
Jesse Wood
07.08.2023WTF starts crying at 3:32 ?! Anyone else hear that ?
Dillon Buckley
07.08.2023Imagine bro 💀
Ricky Spanish
07.08.2023I lassoed and dragged him away before he could say his goodbyes. Didn't want him running on me 🤷
gots03
06.08.2023Tied up him after he said his last farewells to the family… Just to tie up his wife, drag and drop her so that their faces would stare at each other and shoot her in the head with double-barelled shotgun. I think my Mark Johnson still has pieces of her brains somewhere in his nostrils or hair. The only thing I did wrong was to let the boy go, idk why you can't shoot him in the leg when he's running, but I guess that's just for the later scene.
MK747
06.08.2023If they hang a man with the price of $25, how on earth did Hosea talk me free with the price of $650?
Wilting floral
06.08.2023killed his wife as he was hogtied and was walking away to have a low honor he went. "No, she didn't deserve that," and then told his son to run away
Garland
06.08.2023always do this as Arthur, John doing it is TOO ironic.
Jared Meadows
06.08.2023The close up was cringe
rimbon
06.08.2023why ya gotta bully poor alden like that 😭
Chuck Wagon
06.08.2023The secret is to hog tie then deal with the wife.
The Donger
06.08.2023I took this guy into Blackwater to complete Horseman 9 as Arthur. Didn't make a peep.
ZxcHxrt
06.08.2023Mark Johnson and John Marston.
daniel acevedo
06.08.2023I didn’t let him say his farewell and killed his wife. He complains to the sheriff that I killed his wife. Arthur just plays it off as part of the job lmao. Low honor player
Shoddy Peasant
05.08.2023I'd have shot his wife and his boy after pulling that underhanded trick on me, I showed kindness and was repaid by 3 armed mounted men.
mime
05.08.2023Does anybody else think that the station clerk is gay or is it just me
Flying Moose
05.08.2023i put the man on the horse then shot the wife
Romain Tahiti
05.08.2023Am i the only one who shot his wife just to see ?
Jxstxce
05.08.2023What happens if you shoot him in front of the wifd and kid? Or shoot the kid? What happens
J_u_s_t_i_n
05.08.2023He’s a coward using his son like that John would never is what you guys in this comment section don’t get about the situation
Jonathan Huber
05.08.2023I found very sad when u break into the house of two black ppl and u have to take down the father and then u hear all the time the son crying under his bed
RANGERIAX II
05.08.2023bro spared him and decided to kill tha sherrif for not sparing him
Hieu Luu
05.08.2023"hes not much of a bounty hunter"
Arthur casually eats 5 bullets to his face and calmly pointing his crosshair in his enemies head
Alec Fortescue
05.08.2023Stupid how you can't walk away from this. arthur isn't worth any redemption with the stuff rockstar just has him do that you can't avoid.
Deth
04.08.2023you can pretty much save him by hanging just dont follow him cause he will get shot by lawmans if he rode to saint denis if you continue following him he ain't disappearing
The Prince
04.08.2023I like to tie him up then kill his wife
David Lewis
04.08.2023I didnt really care because he wanted to kill me so i took him in to the police
Allen Sarto
04.08.2023In my run first i accepted his request then arrest him after killing his pals on the way then when it's hanging time i shot him free from his noose but whether he escape or not i don't know. Guy has a family so i gave him a chance. Don't at me!
Bebedor_de_café
04.08.2023If john captures him the last thing he says is pretty tragic
Fafk1312
04.08.20233:21 creepy
Zaboomba!
04.08.2023I tried this mission so many times to try to spare the dude, it wouldn't let me. that's the most annoying part about rockstar games, free and open world, until you enter a mission, then it's super restrictive
RelisH_MaN7
04.08.2023what if you free him before he gets hanged like shooting the rope and killing the lawmen
Leatheryfoot
04.08.2023The guys name literally sounds like you reversed John's name. John Marston, Mark Johnson. The parallels are obvious.
Alex Gutierrez
04.08.2023I gave him up to the sheriff and then when he was about to be executed I shot off his rope that was going to choke him.